Robert De Niro

Character: Vito Genovese / Frank Costello

Debra Messing

Character: Bobbie Costello

Cosmo Jarvis

Character: Vincent Gigante

Kathrine Narducci

Character: Anna Genovese

Michael Rispoli

Character: Albert Anastasia

Michael Adler

Character: Senator Tobey

Ed Amatrudo

Character: Rudolph Halley

Joe Bacino

Character: Joe Profaci

Anthony J. Gallo

Character: Tommy Lucchese

Wallace Langham

Character: Senator Estes Kefauver

Louis Mustillo

Character: Joe Bonanno

Frank Piccirillo

Character: Richie Boiardo

Matt Servitto

Character: George Wolf

Robert Uricola

Character: Tony Bender

Belmont Cameli

Character: Frankie Boy

Carrie Lazar

Character: LT. Trooper

James Ciccone

Character: Carlo Gambino

Bob Glouberman

Character: Victor Riesel

Jeffrey Grover

Character: Judge Liebowitz

Jean Zarzour

Character: Elsa Anastasia

Derek Polen

Character: Politician

Abi Van Andel

Character: Judge Peggy Cooper

Zach Meiser

Character: Trooper Vasisko

Dennis Craig Hensley

Character: The Majestic Doorman

Gary Chinn

Character: Doorman

Greg Siewny

Character: Politician

D.J. Stroud

Character: Push Cart Vendor

Sydney Miles

Character: Young Bobby Costello

Joseph Moreland

Character: Juror

Antonio Cipriano

Character: Young Vito

Brian Scolaro

Character: Paul Castellano

Noah Bain Garret

Character: Abe Telvi

Bryant Carroll

Character: Local Reporter #1 Divorce

Jean Claude Leuyer

Character: Assassin

Robert Arce

Character: Keith Norval

Luke Stanton Eddy

Character: Young Frank

Steven Terry Walker

Character: Judge (Angry)

Ashton Wolf

Character: Emcee (Copa)

J. Barrett Cooper

Character: Doctor #2

Wynn Reichert

Character: Doctor #1

Seve Esposito

Character: Joe Bonano Jr.

Rich Williams

Character: Walter Hawley

Christine McBurney

Character: Trish Hawley

Todd Covert

Character: Edwin Barry - Defense Attorney

Mike Seely

Character: Sheriff Crosswell

Robert Gerding

Character: Judge

Amadeo Fusca

Character: Lucky Luciano

Jennie Malone

Character: Copa Nightclub Patron

Robert DiDonato

Character: Edward Guinan

John Dinello

Character: Joe Barbara

James P. Harkins

Character: Detective Jim Mullins

Louie Lawless

Character: Joe the Boss

Wilson Conkwright

Character: Busboy

Curtis Murphy

Character: Shoe Shine Boy

Apollo Bacala

Character: Mover

David Vegh

Character: Warden

Tony Scott Griffith

Character: Shoe Shine Customer

Damian Tanenbaum

Character: Bailiff

Ed Formica

Character: Judge Bentley Morris

Mark Tierno

Character: Juror #1

Jen Ryan

Character: Spectator

Michael T. Davis

Character: Local News Reporter

Mark Axelowitz

Character: Asst District Attorney Kamen

Carl Centofanti

Character: Federal Agent

David Pittinger

Character: Radio Staff

William Cross

Character: Federal Agent

Seth Adair

Character: Driver

Richard Doone

Character: Juror

Shantel Routt

Character: Bessie Smith

Brian D. Schroeder

Character: Nightclub Patron

Frank Cervone

Character: Shopkeeper #1

Sammy Geroulis

Character: Driver

Mark Angel

Character: Senate Probe Hearing

Kevin W. Shiveley

Character: Police Officer

Andy Knode

Character: TV Anchor

Sam Armentrout

Character: Police Officer

Glenn Cunningham

Character: Sgt. Ralph Salerno

Logan Moore

Character: Politician's Wife

Jerry Pope

Character: Bodyguard

Taylor Scott Knight

Character: Baker

Richie Root

Character: Photographer

Kalub James Mills

Character: Journalist

Bill Bower

Character: Spectator

John V. Catalano

Character: Self - Vito Dinner Party Guest

Vincent P. Catalano

Character: Vito (Party Guest)

James M. Daria

Character: Copa Nightclub Patron

Andrew Philpot

Character: Pedestrian

Todd Wallrauch

Character: Paralegal

Jimmy Petrolla

Character: Mob Boss

Mike Schenke

Character: Police Officer

Joshua Innerst

Character: Reporter #1

Charlie Powers

Character: Senator's Aide

Shawn Peavie

Character: Doctor

Chris Borghese

Character: Photographer

Michael Moses

Character: Roof Murder Victim

Corey Daria

Character: Mover

Steve Molla

Character: Reporter

Jerome Agean

Character: Mob Boss (uncredited)

Melissa McDermott Currin

Character: Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)

Max Daniels

Character: Anna's Ex Husband (uncredited)

Annie Elliott

Character: Copa Cigarette Girl (uncredited)

Ron Gorley

Character: Copa Nightclub Patron (uncredited)

Karen Koester

Character: Copa Nightclub Patron (uncredited)

Bobby Leigh

Character: Man on Street (uncredited)

Nabeel Mulla

Character: Mob Driver (uncredited)

David C. Phillippi

Character: Courtroom Lawyer (uncredited)

Jarrod Robbins

Character: Bartender (uncredited)

Peyton Stockdale

Character: Joe Barbara Jr.

Richie Verito

Character: Undercover Federal Agent (uncredited)

Dakota Phillips

Character: Zebra Club Patron (uncredited)