Bobby Driscoll

Character: Peter Pan (voice)

Kathryn Beaumont

Character: Wendy Darling (voice)

Hans Conried

Character: Captain Hook / Mr. Darling (voice)

Bill Thompson

Character: Mr. Smee (voice)

Heather Angel

Character: Mrs. Darling (voice)

Paul Collins

Character: John Darling (voice)

Tommy Luske

Character: Michael Darling (voice)

Candy Candido

Character: Indian Chief (voice)

Tom Conway

Character: Narrator (voice)

June Foray

Character: Mermaid / Squaw (voice) (uncredited)

Margaret Kerry

Character: Mermaid (voice, uncredited)

Jeffrey Silver

Character: Lost Boy (voice, uncredited)

Tony Butala

Character: Lost Boy (voice)

Carol Coombs

Character: (voice) (uncredited)

Karen Kester

Character: (voice) (uncredited)