Alia Shawkat

Character: Brandi Blackbear

Illeana Douglas

Character: Toni Blackbear

Eric Schweig

Character: Tim Blackbear

Ritchie Montgomery

Character: Henry Bracken

Gary Grubbs

Character: John Mack Butler

Simone Carter

Character: Casey

Lucas Till

Character: Kyle Kenney

Laura Slade Wiggins

Character: Kimberley

Nancy McLoughlin

Character: English Teacher

Rebecca Rose

Character: Millicent

Josh Blaylock

Character: Noah Taylor

J.D. Evermore

Character: Mr. Gray

Douglas M. Griffin

Character: Ken Knox

Nakotah LaRance

Character: Tim Blackbear Jr.

Laurel Whitsett

Character: Sarah Carson

Margo Moorer

Character: Judge Meehan

Juli Erickson

Character: Secretary Mrs. Figgis

Hannah McLoughlin

Character: Frail Looking Girl

Kelvin Payton

Character: Science Teacher

Ann Mahoney

Character: Mrs. Carroll

Renee Caldwell

Character: Math Teacher

Nathan Phillips

Character: Medicine Man

Patrick Kirton

Character: Network Reporter

Veronica Mosgrove

Character: Local TV Reporter

Margaret Lawhon

Character: Reporter At School

Christy Wells

Character: Local Reporter

Amanda Bosley

Character: Christian Protester

Kerry Burnette

Character: Fake Beard Kid

Mellinda Craig

Character: News Reporter

Dustin Estis

Character: High School Student

Ron Fagan

Character: School Counselor

Leah Rose Fisher

Character: High School Student

Richard Harold

Character: Local Reporter

Michael J. Hebert

Character: Resource Officer

Daniel Lachman

Character: High School Student

Lacie Manshack

Character: Party Goer

Jonathan Reynolds

Character: Donkey's Rear End

Cynthia Riser

Character: Christian Protester

Mary Alfred Thoma

Character: John Mack Butler's Wife

Amy Updegraff

Character: Brandi's Friend