Doris Day

Character: Aimee Alexander

Ronald Reagan

Character: Grover Cleveland Alexander

Frank Lovejoy

Character: Rogers Hornsby

Eve Miller

Character: Margaret Killefer

James Millican

Character: Bill Killefer

Russ Tamblyn

Character: Willie Alexander

Gordon Jones

Character: George Glasheen

Hugh Sanders

Character: Joe McCarthy

Frank Ferguson

Character: Sam Arrants

Dorothy Adams

Character: Ma Alexander

Bob Lemon

Character: Jesse 'Pop' Haines

Jerry Priddy

Character: Ballplayer

Peanuts Lowery

Character: Ballplayer

George Metkovich

Character: Ballplayer

Irving Noren

Character: Ballplayer

Hank Sauer

Character: Ballplayer

Al Zarilla

Character: Ballplayer

Gene Mauch

Character: Ballplayer

Walter Baldwin

Character: Pa Alexander (uncredited)

Jack Carr

Character: Angry Fan (uncredited)