Sara Bareilles

Character: Jenna Hunterson

Charity Angél Dawson

Character: Becky

Caitlin Houlahan

Character: Dawn Louise Pinkett

Drew Gehling

Character: Dr. Jim Pomatter

Dakin Matthews

Character: Joe

Eric Anderson

Character: Cal

Joe Tippett

Character: Earl Hunterson

Christopher Fitzgerald

Character: Ogie (Oklahoma) Anhorn

Anastacia McCleskey

Character: Nurse Norma

Molly Jobe

Character: Mother

Stephanie Torns

Character: Francine

Nora Winer

Character: Lulu

Matt Deangelis

Character: Ensemble

Henry Gottfried

Character: Ensemble

Max Kumangai

Character: Ensemble

Tyrone Davis Jr.

Character: Ensemble

Andrew Fitch

Character: Ensemble

Emily Koch

Character: Ensemble

Nyla Watson

Character: Ensemble