Ben Stiller

Character: Mike Maxwell

Linda Cardellini

Character: Gretchen Rice

Homer Janson

Character: Justice Kicklighter

Ulysses Janson

Character: Junior Kicklighter

Arlo Janson

Character: Simon Kicklighter

Atlas Janson

Character: Samuel Kicklighter

Toby Huss

Character: Al Wilmington

Maren Heisler

Character: Mia

Edi Patterson

Character: Rose

Tim Heidecker

Character: Deputy Cox

Ari Graynor

Character: Carol (voice)

Ashley Rae Spillers

Character: Barbara (voice)

Lucy Zukaitis

Character: Julia

Bryant Carroll

Character: Security Guard

Louis Heisler

Character: Anthony Biniak

Noah Fisher

Character: Gus

Isabella Steele

Character: Mia’s Friend

Dominick Marrone

Character: Reverend Logan

Vasily Deris

Character: Theater Manager

Jerome Agean

Character: Radio Announcer

Estelle Lapina

Character: Prop Kid #1

Brooks Roseberry

Character: Prop Kid #2

Will Daly

Character: Prop Kid #3

Evan Bartos

Character: Prop Kid #4

Alexander Louis

Character: Gingerbread Man

Rodrigo Almarales

Character: Gingerbread Man Dancer

Jeff Janson

Character: Steve Kicklighter

Melissa Gelfin

Character: Janet Kicklighter

Jenny McManus

Character: Party Guest (uncredited)