Peter Paige

Character: Paul Johnson

Kathy Najimy

Character: Maggie Butler

Anthony Clark

Character: Russell Trotter

Lisa Edelstein

Character: Sarah Faber

Jim Ortlieb

Character: David Berman

Gabrielle Union

Character: Elise Carter

Melanie Lynskey

Character: Susan

Katie O’Grady

Character: Mother #1

Ayanna Berkshire

Character: Mother #2

Don Adler

Character: Grant Sweet

Robert Blanche

Character: Phil

Betty Boyer

Character: Clothing Store Lady

Patrick Dizney

Character: Jim Faber

Heidi Herschbach

Character: Perky Receptionist

Beth Harper

Character: Adoption Agency Lady

Joshua Westhaver

Character: Crunchy Man

Leslie Taylor

Character: Screaming Mom

Kevin Jones

Character: Simon's Dad

Marc Anthony Samuel

Character: Keith

Don Burns

Character: Richard Long

Lori Ferraro

Character: Coffee Shop Clerk

Torrey Cornwell

Character: Lesbian Mom

Victor Morris

Character: Police Sergeant

Ellen Bloodworth

Character: Donut Shop Woman

Brian Pope

Character: Joey's Dad

Maia McCarthy

Character: Young Mother

Brooke Blanchard

Character: Leslie

Brooks McCauley

Character: Tyler

Nina Hambleton

Character: Lindsay

Raymond Burney

Character: Simon

Joshua Pope

Character: Joey

Alexandra Morrison

Character: Six-Year-Old Girl

Jacob Reznicki

Character: Jacob

Madeline Dean

Character: Ashley

Sophie Schoenfeld

Character: Kid #1

Tanner Phelps

Character: Timmy