Elizabeth Montgomery

Character: Lizzie Borden

Fionnula Flanagan

Character: Bridget Sullivan

Ed Flanders

Character: Hosea Knowlton

Katherine Helmond

Character: Emma Borden

Don Porter

Character: George Robinson

Fritz Weaver

Character: Mr. Andrew Borden

Bonnie Bartlett

Character: Sylvia Knowlton

Helen Craig

Character: Mrs. Abby Borden

Hayden Rorke

Character: Julien Ralph

Gloria Stuart

Character: Store customer

John Beal

Character: Dr. Bowen

Alan Hewitt

Character: Mayor Coughlin

Gail Kobe

Character: Alice Russell

Amzie Strickland

Character: Adelaide Churchill

Robert Symonds

Character: Andrew Jennings

Iggie Wolfington

Character: Store Proprietor

John Zaremba

Character: Judge Blaisdell

J. Edward McKinley

Character: Marshall Hilliard

Norman Stuart

Character: Dr. Wood

Jon Lormer

Character: Bailiff

Lynn Wood

Character: Mrs. Raymond

Olan Soule

Character: Eli Bence

Judson Morgan

Character: Justice Morgan

John Alvin

Character: Dr. Draper

Patricia Wilson

Character: Hannah Reagan

Tracie Savage

Character: Young Lizzie

Joan Crosby

Character: Companion

Jason Johnson

Character: Jury Foreman