Edward Norton

Character: Bill Kincaid / Brady Kincaid

Susan Sarandon

Character: Daisy Kincaid

Richard Dreyfuss

Character: Pug Rothbaum

Keri Russell

Character: Janet

Melanie Lynskey

Character: Colleen

Lucy DeVito

Character: Anne Greenstein

Kent Jude Bernard

Character: Philosophy Student

Amelia Campbell

Character: Maggie Harmon

Tim Blake Nelson

Character: Bolger

Randal Reeder

Character: Shaver

Leo Fabian

Character: Waddell

Pruitt Taylor Vince

Character: Big Joe Sharpe

Tina Parker

Character: Sharon

Ty Burrell

Character: Professor Sorenson

Lee Wilkof

Character: Professor Nathan Levy

Josh Pais

Character: Ken Feinman

Lisa Benavides

Character: Suzie Feinman

Steven E. Williams

Character: Synagogue Parishioner (uncredited)

Maggie Siff

Character: Rabbi Zimmerman

Tim Ware

Character: Minister Davies

Ken Cheeseman

Character: Jimmy Fuller

Steve Earle

Character: Buddy Fuller

Lee Wilkof

Character: Professor Levy

Jim Henry

Character: Policeman (uncredited)