James Van Der Beek

Character: Lincoln Rogers Dunnison

Rachael Leigh Cook

Character: Caroline Dukes

Ashton Kutcher

Character: George Durham

Dylan McDermott

Character: Leander McNelly

Usher

Character: Randolph Douglas Scipio

Tom Skerritt

Character: Richard Dukes

Randy Travis

Character: Frank Bones

Leonor Varela

Character: Perdita

Brian Martell

Character: Jean-Pierre Marsele

Alfred Molina

Character: John King Fisher

Billy Morton

Character: Abajo

Kate Newby

Character: Henrietta Dukes

Robert Patrick

Character: Sgt. John Armstrong

Gordon Michaels

Character: Mariachi Guard

Joe Renteria

Character: General Cortinas

Jon Abrahams

Character: Berry Smith

Bob Bancroft

Character: Auctioneer

Stephen Bridgewater

Character: Older Ranger

Jordan Brower

Character: Jake Dunnison

Anthony Crivello

Character: Ringmaster

Oded Fehr

Character: Anton Marsale

Derek Flores

Character: Leary

Breon Gorman

Character: Mrs. Dunnison

Eric Johnson

Character: Rollins

Matt Keeslar

Character: Suh Suh Sam

Matthew Kennedy

Character: Ranch Hand Steve

Marco Leonardi

Character: Jesus Sandoval

Brad Loree

Character: Outlaw #3

David Millbern

Character: Marshall

William Prael

Character: Cale Dukes

A. Alexandra Sanford

Character: Fisher's Prostitute

Jim Shield

Character: Baldbum

Joe Spano

Character: Mr. Dunnison

Vincent Spano

Character: Ed Simms

Jesse G. Thompson

Character: Purdy Dukes

Gareth Williams

Character: Vigilante Vic

James Coburn

Character: Narrator (voice) (uncredited)