Nicolas Cage

Character: John Koestler

Rose Byrne

Character: Diana Wayland

Chandler Canterbury

Character: Caleb Koestler

Ben Mendelsohn

Character: Phil Bergman

Nadia Townsend

Character: Grace Koestler

Terry Camilleri

Character: Cashier

Lara Robinson

Character: Lucinda Embry / Abby Wayland

Adrienne Pickering

Character: Allison

Danielle Carter

Character: Miss Taylor (1959)

Alethea McGrath

Character: Miss Taylor (2009)

David Lennie

Character: Principal Clark (1959)

D.G. Maloney

Character: The Stranger

Alan Hopgood

Character: Rev. Koestler

Joshua Long

Character: Younger Caleb

Tamara Donnellan

Character: Lucinda's Mother

Travis Waite

Character: Lucinda's Father

Liam Hemsworth

Character: Spencer

Harli Ames

Character: Man in Duffle Coat

Alyssa McClelland

Character: Flight Attendant

Gareth Yuen

Character: Donald

Lesley Anne Mitchell

Character: Stacey

Raymond Thomas

Character: Teacher

Angie Diaz

Character: Reporter

Kate Mylius

Character: Student (uncredited)

Sarah Lawrence

Character: New York Model (uncredited)

Carolyn Shakespeare-Allen

Character: Principal (2009)

Nathaniel Kiwi

Character: Paramedic

Blair Venn

Character: Paramedic

Menik Gooneratne

Character: Woman with Baby

Jim Knobeloch

Character: Army General

Steve Mouzakis

Character: Head Paramedic

Sonya Suares

Character: Assistant Paramedic