Laura Linney

Character: Sammy

Mark Ruffalo

Character: Terry

Matthew Broderick

Character: Brian

Jon Tenney

Character: Bob

Rory Culkin

Character: Rudy

J. Smith-Cameron

Character: Mabel

Josh Lucas

Character: Rudy Sr.

Gaby Hoffmann

Character: Sheila

Adam LeFevre

Character: Sheriff Darryl

Amy Ryan

Character: Mrs. Prescott

Michael Countryman

Character: Mr. Prescott

Kenneth Lonergan

Character: Ron

Halley Feiffer

Character: Amy

Whitney Vance

Character: Young Sammy

Peter Kerwin

Character: Young Terry

Betsy Aidem

Character: Minister

Lisa Altomare

Character: Waitress

Nina Garbiras

Character: Nancy

Richard Hummer

Character: Plumber

Kim Parker

Character: Rudy Sr.'s Girlfriend

Allan Gill

Character: Older Cop

Brian Ramage

Character: Young Cop