Tina Fey

Character: Portia Nathan

Ann Harada

Character: Mrs. Lafont

Ben Levin

Character: Junior Lafont

Dan Levy

Character: James

Maggie Keenan-Bolger

Character: Girl on Tour

Gloria Reuben

Character: Corinne

Paul Rudd

Character: John Pressman

Wallace Shawn

Character: Clarence

Elaine Kussack

Character: Abby

Christopher Evan Welch

Character: Brandt

Michael Genadry

Character: Ben

Juliet Brett

Character: Praying Applicant

John Brodsky

Character: Smug Kid

Camille Branton

Character: Gymnast

Sarita Choudhury

Character: Rachael

Michael Sheen

Character: Mark

Ken Barnett

Character: Admissions Counselor

Nat Wolff

Character: Jeremiah

Travis Bratten

Character: Quest Student

Tanisha Long

Character: Quest Student

Nadia Alexander

Character: Quest Student

Karen Pham

Character: Quest Student

Travaris Spears

Character: Nelson

Lily Tomlin

Character: Susannah

Rob Campbell

Character: Richard

Sonya Walger

Character: Helen

Olek Krupa

Character: Polokov

Roby Sobieski

Character: Makeout Guy

Lauren Schaffel

Character: Student at Party

Brian Charles Johnson

Character: Student at Party

Lipica Shah

Character: Student at Party

Jarod Einsohn

Character: Keg Guy

Caliaf St. Aubyn

Character: Keg Guy's Friend

Zita Geoffroy

Character: Tour Group Mom

Laura Jordan

Character: Woman

Zachary Unger

Character: Jeremiah - 8 Years Old

Lisa Emery

Character: Mrs. Pressman

Mihran Slougian

Character: Jeremiah's Dad

Lynne Taylor

Character: Jeremiah's Mom

Brian d'Arcy James

Character: Christopher Flynn

Leigha Hancock

Character: Yulia Karasov

Sarah Quinn

Character: Young Mother

Jason Blaj

Character: Supermarket Kid

David Simins

Character: A Capella Singer

Brad Wilson

Character: A Capella Singer

Ryan McCarty

Character: A Capella Singer

Krishna Choudhary

Character: A Capella Singer

Ricky Jones

Character: A Capella Singer

Thomas Merckens

Character: A Capella Singer

Alan Robert Southworth

Character: A Capella Singer

Chris Bronwell

Character: A Capella Singer

Chris Palermo

Character: A Capella Singer

Anthony Capers

Character: Jeremiah's Buddy

Julia Faye Fisher

Character: Agency Receptionist

Gameela Wright

Character: Woman in Adoption Agency

James P. Anderson

Character: Baxter Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)

Tina Benko

Character: Andrea (uncredited)

Matthew Broadley

Character: Twin Brother (uncredited)

Vanessa Carter

Character: Quest Student (uncredited)

Alix Cross

Character: Quest Student (uncredited)

Jonathon Culver

Character: Quest Student (uncredited)

Giullian Yao Gioiello

Character: Princeton Applicant (uncredited)

Brandon Lee Harris

Character: Office Assistant (uncredited)

Alice Litvak

Character: Twin Sister (uncredited)

Nicole Maggio

Character: Lacrosse Girl (uncredited)

Alexis Molnar

Character: Princeton College Applicant (uncredited)

Meaghan Monaghan

Character: Student (uncredited)

Rachel Moss

Character: Lacrosse Player (uncredited)

Ismaelpeter Casillas Nelson

Character: Cow Milking Expert (uncredited)

Edward Sass III

Character: Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)

Danielle Senk

Character: Lacrosse Player (uncredited)

Natasha Tax

Character: Prep School Girl (uncredited)

Barbara Vincent

Character: Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)

Joshua Hinck

Character: Sebastian