David Pevsner

Character: Ebenezer Scrooge

Tim Kazurinsky

Character: Jacob Marley's Ghost

Rusty Schwimmer

Character: Freda

Bruce Vilanch

Character: Fezziwig

Megan Cavanagh

Character: Terry / Ghost of Christmas Present

Richard Ganoung

Character: Colin

David Shae

Character: Bob Cratchit

Ronnie Kroell

Character: Randy / Ghost of Christmas Past

Drew Anderson

Character: Young Ebenezer Scrooge

Nicholas Bailey

Character: Young Jacob Marley

Christopher Allen

Character: Bill

JoJo Baby

Character: Ghost of Christmas Future / Spectres / Delivery Person

P.J. Powers

Character: Wraith

Scott Duff

Character: Drew

Amy Matheny

Character: Mary

Fawzia Mirza

Character: Marshall

Peter Mohawk

Character: Kyle

Michael Joseph Mitchell

Character: Scrooge's Father

Becca Kaufman

Character: Becca

Richard Knight Jr.

Character: Dick

Tom Downing

Character: Brent

Allison Torem

Character: Franny

Liam Jones

Character: Tiny Tim

Dixon Kaufman

Character: Cassie

Delaney Kaufman

Character: Ruby

Elijah Pendleton

Character: Rafael

Keante Pendleton

Character: Simon

Michael Termine

Character: Pawn Shop Owner

Judith Light

Character: Narrator (voice)