Phil Vischer

Character: George / Sedgewick / Willory / Sir Frederick / Mr. Hibbing / Bob the Tomato / Pirate Spy / Pirate Philippe Pea (voice)

Mike Nawrocki

Character: Elliot / Pirate Jean Claude Pea / Theater Foe / Pirate Spy Sidekick / Pirate with Dummy / Rock Monster Father (voice)

Cam Clarke

Character: Robert the Terrible / The King (voice)

Laura Gerow

Character: Eloise (voice)

Yuri Lowenthal

Character: Alexander (voice)

Alan Lee

Character: Blind Man / One-Eyed Louie (voice)

Cydney Trent

Character: Bernadette (Petunia) (voice)

Keri Pisapia

Character: Ellen (voice)

Megan Murphy

Character: Madame Blueberry (voice)

Sondra Morton Chaffin

Character: Caroline (voice)

Jim Poole

Character: Pirate Scooter Carrot (voice)

Tim Hodge

Character: Jolly Joe / King's Ship Officer / Background Voices (voice)

Drake Lyle

Character: George Jr. / Rock Monster Boy (voice)

Ally Nawrocki

Character: Lucy / Rock Monster Girl (voice)

Patrick Kramer

Character: Collin (voice)

Sloan Yarborough

Character: Photographer (voice)

Joe Spadaford

Character: Jacob Lewis / Stubb Pirate Overlord / Stubb Pirate Coward (voice)

John Wahba

Character: Dungeon Guard / Pirate with Dummy Sidekick (voice)

Colleen Curtis

Character: Theater Customer Woman (voice)

Brian K. Roberts

Character: Steadfast Soldier / Theater Customer Man / Pirate Pilot (voice)

Marissa Collyer

Character: Background Voices (voice)

Michael Fowler

Character: Background Voices (voice) (as Michael 'C.J.' Fowler)

Kurt Heinecke

Character: Background Voices (voice)

Paula Marcus

Character: Background Voices (voice)

J. Chris Wall

Character: Background Voices (voice)

Andy Youssi

Character: Background Voices (voice) (as Andrew Youssi)