Melissa Joan Hart

Character: Sabrina Sawyer

Sherry Miller

Character: Aunt Hilda

Charlene Fernetz

Character: Aunt Zelda

Michelle Beaudoin

Character: Marnie Littlefield

Ryan Reynolds

Character: Seth

Tobias Mehler

Character: Harvey

Lalainia Lindbjerg

Character: Katy Lemore

Laura Harris

Character: Freddie

Kea Wong

Character: Fran

Jo Bates

Character: Coach

Janine Cox

Character: Sales Clerk

Biski Gugushe

Character: Larry

Tyler Labine

Character: Mark

Jim Swansburg

Character: Mr. Dingle

Noel Geer

Character: Jeff

Volton

Character: D.J.

Cory Chetyrbok

Character: Student (uncredited)

Kevin Corey

Character: Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Nick Bakay

Character: Salem (voice)