John Lund

Character: Lance Horton

Brian Donlevy

Character: Charles Quantrill

Audrey Totter

Character: Kate Quantrill / Kitty McCoy

Joan Leslie

Character: Sally Maris

Ben Cooper

Character: Jesse James

James Brown

Character: Frank James

Nina Varela

Character: Mayor Delilah Courtney

Ellen Corby

Character: First Townswoman

Fern Hall

Character: Second Woman

Minerva Urecal

Character: Mrs. Stuart

Jim Davis

Character: Cole Younger

Reed Hadley

Character: Bitterroot Bill Maris

Ann Savage

Character: Glenda

Virginia Christine

Character: Jenny

Marilyn Lindsey

Character: Rose

Gordon Jones

Character: Yankee Sergeant

Nacho Galindo

Character: John Pablo

Frank Ferguson

Character: Bartender

Richard Crane

Character: Yankee Lieutenant (uncredited)

Carl Pitti

Character: Bourreau - Hangman (uncredited)