Gillian Jacobs

Character: Leslie

John Malkovich

Character: Michael

Ryan Simpkins

Character: Young Leslie

Tom Arnold

Character: Alex

Kevin Zegers

Character: Frank

Jermaine Scooter Smith

Character: Young Donnie

Harold Perrineau

Character: Orlando

Jeremy Sisto

Character: Jimmy

Raynold Gideon

Character: Judge Feeney

Cornelia Guest

Character: Mrs. Feeney

Natalie May

Character: Judge's Daughter

Ben Lin

Character: Pa

Alice Lo

Character: Ma

Evan Ross

Character: Donnie

Landall Goolsby

Character: Blackberry John

Raphael Sbarge

Character: Mr. Whitehead

Evan Peters

Character: Rachel / Brian

Kyle Gallner

Character: Ratboy

Ty Simpkins

Character: Dylan Whitehead

Max Van Ville

Character: Surf

Shiloh Fernandez

Character: Cooper

Shontae Saldana

Character: Baby Loco