Anthony Dexter

Character: Capt. William Kidd

Eva Gabor

Character: Judith Duvall

Alan Hale Jr.

Character: Jay Simpson

James Seay

Character: Bellomont

Richard Karlan

Character: Capt. Avery

Noel Cravat

Character: L'ollinaise

Lyle Talbot

Character: Capt. Pace

Sonia Sorel

Character: Anne Bonney

Michael Ross

Character: Blackbeard

Jack Reitzen

Character: Bartholomew

Robert Long

Character: Calico Jack

William Cottrell

Character: Roberts (as Bill Cottrell)

William Tannen

Character: Steve Castle (as Bill Tannen)

John Crawford

Character: Bonnett

William Schallert

Character: Priest (uncredited)