Craig Robinson

Character: Anti-Christ

Anna Kendrick

Character: Lindsey Lewis

John Francis Daley

Character: Ben House

Ken Jeong

Character: God

Rob Corddry

Character: Mr. House

Thomas Lennon

Character: Mr. Murphy

Tyler Labine

Character: Shorter Wraith

Ana Gasteyer

Character: Mrs. Lewis

Paul Scheer

Character: Security Wraith

Rob Huebel

Character: Morgan

Mark Sweatman

Character: Jesus

Calum Worthy

Character: Clark Lewis

John Michael Higgins

Character: Mr. Lewis