Tony Goldwyn

Character: Joshua

F. Murray Abraham

Character: Father Tardone

Kurt Fuller

Character: Father Pat Hayes

Stacy Edwards

Character: Maggie

Giancarlo Giannini

Character: The Pope

Eddie Bo Smith Jr.

Character: Theo

Michael Guido

Character: Aaron

Matt Zeigler

Character: Kevin

Colleen Camp

Character: Joan Casey

Marc Grapey

Character: Steve Casey (as Mark Grapey)

Rich Komenich

Character: Ray Persini

Dale Calandra

Character: Leo Persini

Cedric Young

Character: Charlie

Tim Grimm

Character: Bishop Anderson

Jordan Allen

Character: Michael Reed

James Meeks

Character: Muntoe

Bernie Landis

Character: Rabbi Szeneth

John Sierros

Character: Policeman (credit only)

David Pasquesi

Character: Eli Cohen

Tom Brainard

Character: Young Pastor

Tim Decker

Character: Reverend Daily

Linsey Page Morton

Character: Paulina

Beth Lacke

Character: Sally

Tom Roland

Character: Cardinal Riccardo

Coburn Goss

Character: Father Delorenzo (as Coby Goss)

Jim Carrane

Character: Father Tumelo

Ilio Bruno

Character: Cardinal Napoli

Barrie D. Buckner Jr.

Character: Henry (as Barrie D. Buckner)

Jason Borgardt

Character: Randall

Ken Stimson

Character: Reverend Williams

Bob O'Donnell

Character: Bishop Representative

Tai Anderson

Character: Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Brad Avery

Character: Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

David Carr

Character: Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Mark Lee

Character: Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Mac Powell

Character: Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"