Johnny Mack Brown

Character: Billy the Kid

Wallace Beery

Character: Pat Garrett

Kay Johnson

Character: Claire

Karl Dane

Character: Swenson

Wyndham Standing

Character: John W. Tunston

Russell Simpson

Character: Angus McSween

Blanche Friderici

Character: Mrs. McSween

Roscoe Ates

Character: Old Stuff

Warner Richmond

Character: Bob Ballinger

James A. Marcus

Character: William P. Donovan

Nelson McDowell

Character: Hatfield

Jack Carlyle

Character: Dick Brewer

John Beck

Character: Butterworth

Chris-Pin Martin

Character: Santiago

Marguerita Padula

Character: Nicky Whoosiz

Aggie Herring

Character: Mrs. Hatfield

Hank Bell

Character: Henchman Polka Dot (uncredited)

Buck Bucko

Character: Cowhand (uncredited)

Roy Bucko

Character: Posseman (uncredited)

Bob Card

Character: Cowhand (uncredited)

Don Coleman

Character: Cowhand Tom O'Fallon (uncredited)

Frank Ellis

Character: Henchman Joe (uncredited)

Frank Hagney

Character: Bert Grant (uncredited)

Soledad Jiménez

Character: Santiago's Mother (uncredited)

Bud McClure

Character: Townsman (uncredited)

Sarah Padden

Character: Homesteader Mrs. Foster (uncredited)

Frank Reicher

Character: General Lew Wallace (uncredited)

Carl Stockdale

Character: Homesteader Mr. Foster (uncredited)

Blackjack Ward

Character: Outlaw (uncredited)