Mark Webber

Character: William Harding

Catalina Sandino Moreno

Character: Sarah

Sônia Braga

Character: Mrs. Garcia

Ethan Hawke

Character: Vince

Josh Zuckerman

Character: Decker

Laura Linney

Character: Jesse

Michelle Williams

Character: Samantha

Daniel Ross Owens

Character: Young Vince (as Daniel Ross)

Glen Powell

Character: John Jagerman

Anne Clarke

Character: Young Jesse

Cherami Leigh

Character: Danielle

Jesse Harris

Character: Dave Afton

Bill Dobrow

Character: Drummer

Jon Fowler

Character: Bassist

Guyora Kats

Character: Pianist/Accordian Player

Nick McDonnel

Character: Artsy Guy

Alexandra Daddario

Character: Kim

Jonathan Marc Sherman

Character: Party Philosopher

Richard Linklater

Character: John Wayne Enthusiast

Ryan Hawke

Character: Williamsburg Hip Girl (as Ryan Shawhughes)

Iraida Polanco

Character: Proprietor

Gabriel Rivera

Character: Guitar Player

Greta Gaines

Character: Faye

Frank Whaley

Character: Harris

Lynn Cohen

Character: Harris's Mother

John Patrick Shanley

Character: Priest

Elissabeth Blofson

Character: Kissing Couple

Ben Dickey

Character: Kissing Couple (as Benjamin Dickey)

Lara Theodos

Character: Waitress