Jesse Eisenberg

Character: Charlie Banks

Jason Ritter

Character: Mick Leary

Eva Amurri

Character: Mary

Christopher Rodriguez Marquette

Character: Danny Bowman

Sebastian Stan

Character: Leo Reilly

Gloria Votsis

Character: Nia

Danny A. Abeckaser

Character: Arresting Officer

Declan Baldwin

Character: Detective Lazaroff

Emily Boisseau

Character: Girl In Danny's Class

Dennis Boutsikaris

Character: Mr. Banks

Olivia Keister

Character: Michelle

Amanda George

Character: Glee Club Member

Patrick Pitu

Character: Suicide Witness

Steven Hinkle

Character: Young Charlie

Hunter Gallagher

Character: Older Kid