Don Knotts

Character: Dr. Jesse W. Heywood

Barbara Rhoades

Character: Penelope 'Bad Penny' Cushings

Jackie Coogan

Character: Matthew Basch

Ruth McDevitt

Character: Mrs. Olive Heywood

Frank McGrath

Character: Mr. Remington

Terry Wilson

Character: Welsh

Carl Ballantine

Character: Abel Swanson

Pat Morita

Character: Wong

Robert Yuro

Character: Arnold the Kid

Herb Voland

Character: Dr. Friedlander

Fay DeWitt

Character: Violet

Dub Taylor

Character: Pop Cushings

Hope Summers

Character: Celia

Dick Wilson

Character: Black Eagle (Indian chief)

Don 'Red' Barry

Character: Rev. Zachary Gant

Vaughn Taylor

Character: Rev. Longbaugh

Ed Peck

Character: Sheriff

Edward Faulkner

Character: Marshal Sam Huggins

Arthur Space

Character: Sheriff Tolliver

Greg Mullavey

Character: Phelps - Dental Student

Fred Aldrich

Character: Passerby (uncredited)

E.J. André

Character: Will Banks

John Aniston

Character: Indian (uncredited)

Argentina Brunetti

Character: Squaw (uncredited)

Claudia Bryar

Character: Mrs. Remington

Paul Bryar

Character: Man at Bar (uncredited)

Noble 'Kid' Chissell

Character: Townsman (uncredited)

William Christopher

Character: Hotel Manager (uncredited)

Frank Coghlan Jr.

Character: Man at Bar (uncredited)

Warde Donovan

Character: Townsman (uncredited)

Mickey Finn

Character: Father (uncredited)

Myron Healey

Character: Stage Passenger (uncredited)

Charles Horvath

Character: Indian Warrior (uncredited)

Clyde Howdy

Character: Man (uncredited)

I. Stanford Jolley

Character: Bearded Stage Passenger (uncredited)

Gil Lamb

Character: Slosh White - Drunk

James McHale

Character: Conductor (uncredited)

Tina Menard

Character: Squaw (uncredited)

Kathryn Minner

Character: 96-Year-Old Woman (uncredited)

Dorothy Neumann

Character: Mrs. Eva Longbaugh

Eddie Quillan

Character: Train Porter (uncredited)

Bill Quinn

Character: U.S. Marshal Arthur Bates

Rodd Redwing

Character: White Buffalo (uncredited)

Benny Rubin

Character: Man at Bar (uncredited)

Naomi Stevens

Character: Squaw (uncredited)

Boyd Stockman

Character: Stage Driver (uncredited)

Leonard Stone

Character: Bartender (uncredited)

Lorna Thayer

Character: Saloon Girl (uncredited)

Peggy Mondo

Character: Indian Woman in Stagecoach

Jim Boles

Character: Big Spring Townsman (uncredited)

King Moody

Character: Ernie