Dwayne Johnson

Character: Derek Thompson / Tooth Fairy

Stephen Merchant

Character: Tracy

Ashley Judd

Character: Carly

Julie Andrews

Character: Lily

Ryan Sheckler

Character: Mick Donnelly

Seth MacFarlane

Character: Ziggy

Destiny Whitlock

Character: Tess

Chase Ellison

Character: Randy

Darien Provost

Character: Gabe

Alex Ferris

Character: Shelter Cove Kid

Nicole Muñoz

Character: Kelly

Brendan Meyer

Character: Ben

Josh Emerson

Character: Kyle

Brandon T. Jackson

Character: Duke

Dan Joffre

Character: Tooth Fairy #1

Ellie Harvie

Character: Permit Woman

Barclay Hope

Character: Coach

Michael Daingerfield

Character: Announcer

Dale Wolfe

Character: Color Commentator

Anthony Bewlz

Character: Brad

Brendan Penny

Character: Josh

Lee Tichon

Character: Andreas

Jill Morrison

Character: Shelter Cove Mom

Rukiya Bernard

Character: Amnesia Woman

Maya Washington

Character: Amnesia Daughter

Daniel Bacon

Character: Fan

Christina Schild

Character: Poltergeist Woman

Nicholas Carella

Character: Poltergeist Man

Derek Gilroy

Character: Crazed Fan

Brendan Beiser

Character: Teddy's Dad

Fiona Hogan

Character: Scared Woman

Peter Kelamis

Character: Talent Show Teacher

Steve Levy

Character: Himself

Candus Churchill

Character: Amnesia Grandma

David Quinlan

Character: Gabe's Dad

John Tench

Character: Inmate

Ron Toffolo

Character: Sports Reporter

Stephen Holmes

Character: Shelter Cove Dad

Billy Crystal

Character: Jerry (uncredited)