Olympia Dukakis

Character: Judy Hillerman

Jim Gaffigan

Character: Sandie

Judy Greer

Character: Allison Burbage

Maggie Gyllenhaal

Character: Emme Keeler

Tom McCarthy

Character: Davie Burbage

Sharat Saxena

Character: Satish

Naseeruddin Shah

Character: Avinash aka "Avi"

Tony Shalhoub

Character: Dr. Trabulous

Stephen Colbert

Character: Principal Peersall

Dick Latessa

Character: Jerry Binder

Will Arnett

Character: Danny Keeler

Seth Gilliam

Character: Clayton

Anita Gillette

Character: Lainie

Julie Dretzin

Character: Julie Driscoll

Edie Falco

Character: Safarah Polsky

Jim Parsons

Character: Justin

Rosemarie DeWitt

Character: Debbie

Alexis Dziena

Character: Angie (scenes deleted)