Jonah Hill

Character: Michael Finkel

James Franco

Character: Christian Longo

Felicity Jones

Character: Jill Barker

Maria Dizzia

Character: Mary Jane Longo

Ethan Suplee

Character: Pat Frato

Robert John Burke

Character: Greg Ganley

Charlotte Driscoll

Character: Sadie Longo

Kohl Sudduth

Character: Police Officer

Conor Kikot

Character: Zach Longo

Stella Rae Payne

Character: Madison Longo

Byron Jennings

Character: Judge Odenkirk

Gretchen Mol

Character: Karen

Betty Gilpin

Character: Cheryl

Seth Barrish

Character: Blaise

Robert Stanton

Character: Jeffrey Gregg

Michael Countryman

Character: Coroner

Steve Routman

Character: Jack Pool

Genevieve Angelson

Character: Tina Alvis

Adam Mucci

Character: Courtroom Sheriff

David Wilson Barnes

Character: Corey Douglas

William Jackson Harper

Character: Zak Rausch

Sam Rosen

Character: Steve Mensah

Mara Hobel

Character: Jail Receptionist

David Pittu

Character: Marcus Lickermann

Auden Thornton

Character: Lena

Ngo Okafor

Character: Ibrahim

Uchenna Onuaguluchi

Character: Madou

Maryann Plunkett

Character: Maureen Duffy

Joseph Harrell

Character: Visiting Room Guard #1

Mike Houston

Character: Visiting Room Guard #2

Rosemary Howard

Character: Jury Forewoman

Joel Marsh Garland

Character: Dan Pegg

Dana Eskelson

Character: Joy Longo

Peter Francis James

Character: Colin Parker

Edward James Hyland

Character: Mr. Longo

Johanna Day

Character: Beth Tickler

Georgia Ford

Character: Young Woman

Loudon Wainwright III

Character: Older Man

Julie Sharbutt

Character: Female MSU Worker

Eleanor Hutchins

Character: Middle-Aged Woman

Rebecca Henderson

Character: Ellen Parks

Jay Ferraro

Character: Geoffrey J. Ploobtark

Bill Walters

Character: Inmate (uncredited)

Booch O'Connell

Character: Girl in Playground / Student (uncredited)