Tyler Labine

Character: Barry

Damon Wayans Jr.

Character: Desmond

Lucy Punch

Character: Melanie Miller

Hayes MacArthur

Character: Rafe

Amanda Lund

Character: Rachel

Frankie Shaw

Character: Camille

Wyatt Oleff

Character: JT

Ginger Gonzaga

Character: Juanita

Ed Helms

Character: Ben

Joe Lo Truglio

Character: Sammy

Jerry Minor

Character: Taxi Driver

Lauren Miller Rogen

Character: Leslie

Thomas Middleditch

Character: Kurt

Brian Huskey

Character: Minister Hagen

Brett Gelman

Character: Goker

Vivian Bang

Character: Woman at Taxi Stand

Liza Lapira

Character: Single Mom at Wedding

Karissa Vacker

Character: Juliet

Brooke Josephson

Character: Sarah

Gabrielle Conforti

Character: Angry Woman In Audience

Sam Valentine

Character: Girl at Bar