Sebastian Cabot

Character: Kris Kringle

Jane Alexander

Character: Karen Walker

David Hartman

Character: Bill Schaffner

Suzanne Davidson

Character: Susan Walker

Jim Backus

Character: Shellhammer

Roddy McDowall

Character: Dr. Sawyer

Tom Bosley

Character: Judge Harper

David Doyle

Character: Mr. Macy

Ellen Weston

Character: Celeste

Roland Winters

Character: Mr. Gimbel

Barry Greenberg

Character: Alfred

James Gregory

Character: District Attorney

Jason Wingreen

Character: Halloran

Conrad Janis

Character: Dr. Pierce

Pepe Serna

Character: Y Leader

Jerry Hardin

Character: Bellevue Doctor (uncredited)