Dave Foley

Character: Wayne (voice)

Sarah Chalke

Character: Magee (voice)

Derek Richardson

Character: Lanny (voice)

Mason Cotton

Character: Timmy Terwelp (voice)

David DeLuise

Character: Dancer (voice)

Peter Jacobson

Character: Waterkotte (voice)

Lino DiSalvo

Character: Gristletoe Joe (voice)

William Morgan Sheppard

Character: Big Guy (voice)

Nathan Greno

Character: Dasher (voice)

Hayes MacArthur

Character: Thrasher (voice)

Kevin Deters

Character: Brian (voice)

Kasha Kropinski

Character: Miss Holly (voice)

Adam Shapiro

Character: Coal Elf #1 (voice)

Stevie Wermers-Skelton

Character: Rev-up elf (voice)