James Franco

Character: Michael Glatze

Zachary Quinto

Character: Bennett

Emma Roberts

Character: Rebekah Fuller

Daryl Hannah

Character: Deborah

Lesley Ann Warren

Character: Susan

Avan Jogia

Character: Nico

Charlie Carver

Character: Tyler

Devon Graye

Character: Cory

Evie Thompson

Character: Nicole

Leven Rambin

Character: Catherine

Ahna O'Reilly

Character: Actress

Jefferson Mays

Character: Preacher Teacher

Jan Maxwell

Character: Coltry

Nick Rehberger

Character: Adam

Kevin Cahoon

Character: Peter

Blake Lee

Character: Benoit Denizet-Lewis

Jacob Loeb

Character: Teddy

Daniel Polo

Character: Paul

Deidre Goodwin

Character: Cheryl

Blake Young-Fountain

Character: Chris

Vince Jolivette

Character: Pastor Mike

Jenna Leigh Green

Character: Emergency Room Doctor

Amelia Campbell

Character: Judy Shepard

Patrick Page

Character: Bible Teacher

Lance Roberts

Character: Bishop

Eva Augustina Sinotte

Character: Sexy Lady / Eva

Juan Castano

Character: Anthony

Kanoa Goo

Character: Bible Student

Anna Myrha

Character: Buddhist Advisor

Joe Baken

Character: Jeremy

Jaime Cepero

Character: Kid

Ruthie Ann Miles

Character: Kid

Raymond T. Williams

Character: Heart Specialist

Sophie Savides

Character: Crying Girl

Ella Dershowitz

Character: Liberty Student 1

Reema Sampat

Character: Liberty Student 2

Anna Suzuki

Character: Drunk Friend 1

Anni Weisband

Character: Drunk Friend 2

Patrick John Fagan

Character: Paul's Boyfriend

Allie Gallerani

Character: Derica

Laura Ling

Character: News Reporter