Cheyenne Jackson

Character: Eli Faisel

Anthony Rapp

Character: Logan Joyce

Jessica Richards

Character: Rose

Mitchell Jarvis

Character: Shakespeare / Janitor

Kelsey Carthew

Character: Simonia

Chasen Bauer

Character: Windsor Bisby

Nicole Tompkins

Character: Arden

Philip Labes

Character: Jay

Christopher Matias Aguila

Character: Terry

Marquis Wood

Character: Marcus Robertson

Camille Cregan

Character: Penny

Stacie Mitchell

Character: Keyla

Pamela Bowen

Character: Ms. Wilt

Harrison White

Character: Board President

Chuck Lines

Character: Tech Director

Thessa Mloe

Character: Techie #2

Dia Tequali

Character: Fairy #1

Dahlia Tequali

Character: Fairy #2

Baker Chase Powell

Character: Theseus

Maisie Klompus

Character: Hippolyta

Oscar Rodriguez

Character: Philostrate

Nick Zayas

Character: Quince

Ally Cron-DeVico

Character: Flute

Joey Luthman

Character: Lysander

Timmy Lee

Character: Demetrius

Kristen Corona

Character: Helena

Jennifer Newton

Character: Mother

Robert Paul Taylor

Character: Gym Teacher

Ricco Ross

Character: Mr. Robertson