Denis Leary

Character: Mr. Beal

Joseph Cross

Character: Joshua Beal

Rosie O'Donnell

Character: Sister Terry

Dana Delany

Character: Mrs. Beal

Timothy Reifsnyder

Character: Dave O'Hara

Camryn Manheim

Character: Sister Sophia

Julia Stiles

Character: Neena Beal

Dan Lauria

Character: Father Peters

Robert Loggia

Character: Grandpa Beal

Stefan Niemczyk

Character: Frank Benton

Michael Shulman

Character: Robert Brickman

Marc H. Glick

Character: Father Sebastian

Joey Perillo

Character: Mr. Waltman

Jerry Walsh

Character: Football Coach

Heather Casler

Character: Hope