Jason Ritter

Character: Peter

Jess Weixler

Character: Vandy

Jesse L. Martin

Character: Paul

Tracie Thoms

Character: Marissa

Noah Bean

Character: Andrew

David Rasche

Character: Alan

Bobby Aiello

Character: Male Bartender

Bruce Altman

Character: Dad

Dana Eskelson

Character: Emma

Kristina Klebe

Character: Michelle

Lawrence Michael Levine

Character: Mike

Zak Orth

Character: Keith

Maryann Plunkett

Character: Mom

Gregg Prosser

Character: Wedding Guest