Jon Stewart

Character: Host

Kevin Clash

Character: Elmo

Fran Brill

Character: Zoe / Prairie Dawn / Roxie Marie (voice)

Carmen Osbahr

Character: Rosita (voice)

Frank Oz

Character: Grover / Cookie Monster / Bert (voice)

Caroll Spinney

Character: Big Bird / Oscar the Grouch (voice)

Steve Whitmire

Character: Kermit the Frog / Ernie (voice)

Jerry Nelson

Character: The Count / Two-Headed Monster (1) / Biff (voice)

Joey Mazzarino

Character: Horatio / Papa Bear / Elephant (voice)

David Rudman

Character: Baby Bear / Two-Headed Monster (2) / Sparky / Penguin (voice)

Martin P. Robinson

Character: Telly / Mr. Snuffleupagus / Slimey / Yip-Yip (voice)

Bryant Young

Character: Mr. Snuffleupagus (back half)

Roscoe Orman

Character: Gordon

Sonia Manzano

Character: Maria

Ruth Buzzi

Character: Ruthie

Emilio Delgado

Character: Luis

Loretta Long

Character: Susan

Bob McGrath

Character: Bob

Linda Bove

Character: Linda

David Langston Smyrl

Character: Mr. Handford

Alison Bartlett

Character: Gina

Terry Ellis

Character: Self - En Vogue

Cindy Herron

Character: Self - En Vogue

Maxine Jones

Character: Self - En Vogue

Dawn Robinson

Character: Self - En Vogue

Lauryn Hill

Character: Self - The Fugees

Wyclef Jean

Character: Self - The Fugees

Pras Michel

Character: Self - The Fugees

John Timothy Burton

Character: Self - The Mighty Mighty Bosstones

Tyra Banks

Character: Self

Richard Belzer

Character: Self

Jimmy Buffett

Character: Self

Cindy Crawford

Character: Self

Gloria Estefan

Character: Self

Jeff Garlin

Character: Self

David Alan Grier

Character: Self

Kenny Loggins

Character: Self

Rosie O'Donnell

Character: Self

Andy Richter

Character: Self

Chris Rock

Character: Self

Shawn Colvin

Character: Self

Richard Harris

Character: Self (archive footage)

Jada Pinkett Smith

Character: Self (archive footage)

Lora Lee Ecobelli

Character: Crazy Director (uncredited)

Judy Prianti

Character: Make-up Lady (uncredited)

Heidi Berg

Character: Oinker Sister (voice) (uncredited)

Cheryl Hardwick

Character: Oinker Sister (voice) (uncredited)

Bill Corsair

Character: Hank the Handyman (uncredited)

Jenn Pinto

Character: Kid (uncredited)

Tony Bennett

Character: Self (archive footage) (uncredited)

Conan O'Brien

Character: Self (uncredited)

Will Smith

Character: Self (archive footage)

Ivy Austin

Character: Oinker Sister (voice) (uncredited)

Abe Acay

Character: Child Mambo Dancer (uncredited)

Pam Arciero

Character: Additional Muppet (voice)

Peter Linz

Character: Additional Muppet (voice)

Noel MacNeal

Character: Additional Muppet (voice)

Jim Martin

Character: Additional Muppet (voice)

Dicky Barrett

Character: Self