Ben Johnson

Character: Travis Blue

Joanne Dru

Character: Denver

Harry Carey, Jr.

Character: Sandy

Ward Bond

Character: Elder Wiggs

Charles Kemper

Character: Uncle Shiloh Clegg

Alan Mowbray

Character: Dr. A. Locksley Hall

Jane Darwell

Character: Sister Ledyard

Ruth Clifford

Character: Fleuretty Phyffe

Russell Simpson

Character: Adam Perkins

Kathleen O'Malley

Character: Prudence Perkins

James Arness

Character: Floyd Clegg

Francis Ford

Character: Mr. Peachtree

Fred Libby

Character: Reese Clegg

Jim Thorpe

Character: Navajo Indian

Mickey Simpson

Character: Jesse Clegg

Cliff Lyons

Character: Marshal of Crystal City

Don Summers

Character: Sam Jenkins

Movita

Character: Young Navajo Indian

Hank Worden

Character: Luke Clegg

Chuck Hayward

Character: Jackson (uncredited)

Danny Borzage

Character: Accordionist (uncredited)

Lee Bradley

Character: Leader of the Navajo Band (uncredited)

Nora Bush

Character: Settler (uncredited)

Jane Crowley

Character: Settler (uncredited)

Tex Holden

Character: Settler (uncredited)

George Huggins

Character: Settler (uncredited)

Fred Kennedy

Character: Settler (uncredited)

Al Kunde

Character: Fiddler (uncredited)

Ann Kunde

Character: Settler (uncredited)

Frank McGrath

Character: Posse Member (uncredited)

Evelyn Moriarty

Character: Settler (uncredited)

Eleanore Vogel

Character: Settler (uncredited)