Donald Glover

Character: Jason Rogers

Aubrey Plaza

Character: Kelly Peters

Dominic Dierkes

Character: Charlie Day

D.C. Pierson

Character: Duncan Wheeler

Matt Walsh

Character: Jim

Glenn Kalison

Character: Robert

Peter Saati

Character: Leroy

Kay Cannon

Character: Destiny

Bobby Moynihan

Character: Jordy

John Lutz

Character: Frank

Robbie Sublett

Character: Ricky Appleman

Tom Shillue

Character: Alan McGinty

Ellie Kemper

Character: Jamie

Kevin Dotcom Brown

Character: Bouncer

Dan Eckman

Character: Bread Squeezer

Will Hines

Character: Mr. Stevens

Meggie McFadden

Character: Cathy

Kristopher Kling

Character: Sam

Ben Schwartz

Character: Dougie's Buddy

Ron Simons

Character: Mr. Rogers

Nick Packard

Character: Dougie

Daphne Ciccarelle

Character: Brianna

Gregory Burke

Character: Football Player

Jon Daly

Character: Greg

Joe James

Character: Security Guard (uncredited)