Jay Baruchel

Character: Reed Fish

Alexis Bledel

Character: Kate

Victor Rasuk

Character: Frank Cortez

Schuyler Fisk

Character: Jill

A. J. Cook

Character: Theresa

Katey Sagal

Character: Maureen

Shiri Appleby

Character: Jill Cavanaugh

Chris Parnell

Character: Ralph

Valerie Azlynn

Character: Kate Peterson

DJ Qualls

Character: Andrew

Blake Clark

Character: Irv

Tommy Dewey

Character: Rex

Jim Cody Williams

Character: Cowboy

Boti Bliss

Character: Waitress

Rossif Sutherland

Character: Gabe

David Beggs

Character: Farmer

Jackie Benoit

Character: Imogene Sandstrom

Eugene Smith

Character: Preacher

Reed Fish

Character: John Penner

Peter Alwazzan

Character: Radio Show Caller (voice)

Scott Laster

Character: Floyd Fish (voice)

Todd Fjelsted

Character: Bartender (uncredited)