Jason Ritter

Character: Bill Hart

Jaime King

Character: Beth Hart

Marianna Palka

Character: Jill Hart

Brighton Sharbino

Character: Tiffany Hart

Rio Mangini

Character: Max Hart

Kingston Foster

Character: Cindy Hart

Martin Starr

Character: Todd

Jason Maybaum

Character: Jed

Sol Rodriguez

Character: Annabelle

Liisa Lee

Character: Dog voice

Caroline Aaron

Character: Nana

Roger Guenveur Smith

Character: Steven Sheriff

Bill Smitrovich

Character: Papa

Ren Hanami

Character: Family Lawyer

Asia Mattu

Character: Dog voice

Jaime Moyer

Character: Plumber Joe

Eric Edelstein

Character: (uncredited)