Samantha Smedley

Character: Teodora Castelucci

Tyler Ankenman

Character: Palmer

Emily Ryan Reed

Character: Shannon

Sarah Sumner

Character: Yara

Andres De Vengoechea

Character: Dan

Augustus Wilson

Character: Ryan

Jennifer Suter

Character: Caroline Maloney

Alyssa Accardo

Character: Shelby

Alexandra Simota

Character: Katherine Muffburn

Rachael Feldman

Character: Scout

Shaun Kennedy

Character: Noah

Christina Cappelli

Character: Ruthie

Omar Pelaez

Character: Tiki

Amy Stringer

Character: Aubrey

Zack Abramowitz

Character: John-A-Ton

Peter Fiorentino

Character: Yung Taco

Jarrod Allan

Character: Hamlit

Robert Molinari

Character: Teddy's Dad

Andrew Gonzalez

Character: Victor

Francesca Redeye

Character: GiGi

Brittini Schreiber

Character: Billie

Alexandra Noland

Character: Becca

Alex McKelley

Character: Leigh

Pedro Villalta

Character: Cameron

Trent Stone

Character: God (voice)

Jaine Ye

Character: Lauren

Eli Cox

Character: Michael

Dawn Aneada

Character: Polly

Hannah Abney

Character: Casting Director