Cary Elwes

Character: Kingsley Amis

Diane Kruger

Character: Patricia Rickels

Marie Avgeropoulos

Character: Jean Ann Jollett

Brad Dourif

Character: Arthur Ducoing

Nick Offerman

Character: Bobby Byrne

Thomas Mann

Character: John Kennedy Toole

Susan Sarandon

Character: Thelma Toole

Desmond Harrington

Character: Jack Kerouac

Annalise Basso

Character: Martha

Aidan Quinn

Character: Barnet Rosset

Skyler Samuels

Character: Ruth

Stephen Tobolowsky

Character: The Abbot

François Arnaud

Character: Dave Kubach

Brendan Coyle

Character: Milton Rickels

Denis O'Hare

Character: John Dewey Toole

Roger Bart

Character: Les Phillabaum

David Paymer

Character: Stanley Kauffmann

Nick Gehlfuss

Character: Joel Fletcher

Arliss Howard

Character: Shelby Foote

Olivia Crocicchia

Character: Myrna

Billy Slaughter

Character: