Kimberly Williams-Paisley

Character: Ida Graber

Tammy Blanchard

Character: Amy Roberts

Fay Masterson

Character: Jill Green

Madison Mason

Character: Levi Brennaman

Gary Graham

Character: Henry Taskey

Darcy Rose Byrnes

Character: Rebecca Knepp

Karley Scott Collins

Character: Katie Graber

Eugene Byrd

Character: Danny

Bruce Nozick

Character: Leonard

Amy Sloan

Character: Rachel Knepp

John Churchill

Character: Charlie Roberts

Madison Davenport

Character: Mary Beth Graber

Matt Letscher

Character: Gideon Graber

Eric Nenninger

Character: State Trooper

Willow Geer

Character: Judith

Christopher Curry

Character: Minister

Kate Fuglei

Character: Shelly

Jim Metzler

Character: Sheriff

Bob Rumnock

Character: Reporter

Emilee Wallace

Character: Teacher Ruth

Jessica Dickey

Character: Melinda

Chloe Madison

Character: Sarah Knepp

Taylor Ann Thompson

Character: Hannah

Trevor Thompson

Character: Jacob

David Mazouz

Character: Andy Roberts

Dale Wade Davis

Character: Rachel's Husband

Joel Schmidt

Character: Melinda's Husband

David Curtis

Character: Amish Elder

Sammy Jack

Character: Knepp Boy #1

Gabriel Welch

Character: Knepp Boy #2

Elijah Tadros

Character: Ryan Roberts

Caleb Babcock

Character: Schoolboy (uncredited)

Daphne Blunt

Character: Lilly (uncredited)

Isabella Interian

Character: Lydia (uncredited)

Marcus Shultz

Character: Knepp Teenager (uncredited)

Johnny Wilson

Character: Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)