Carl Crew

Character: Jeffrey Dahmer

Christopher 'CJ' Smith

Character: Young Jeffrey Dahmer

Donna Stewart Bowen

Character: Mother

Jeanne Bascom

Character: Grandmother

Cassidy Phillips

Character: Steven

G-Jo Reed

Character: Steve

Rowdy Jackson

Character: Richard

Andrew Christian English

Character: Anthony

Don Jose Christian

Character: Anthony

Douglas Moore

Character: Raymond

Lando St. Clair

Character: Edward

Dominic Anthony

Character: Ernest / Matt

John Anthony Williams

Character: David

Peter Napoles

Character: Konerak

Aaron Braxton

Character: Tracy

Alex Scott

Character: Ronald

Keith Gearhart

Character: James

Cornelius Williams

Character: Bobby

Rhonno Ket

Character: Sounthome

Melanite Haymon

Character: Sandra

Michelle Silveira

Character: Glenda

Christian Voss

Character: Bar Pick-Up

Jordan Cox

Character: Baby

Jill Cox

Character: Lady with Baby

Laura Tesone

Character: Lady in Car

Rick Bower

Character: Clergyman

Marklen Kennedy

Character: Composite Victim

Lance Mitchell

Character: Prostitute / Victim

Lisa Marks

Character: Probation Officer

Deane Nelson

Character: Police Officer

Lana Lloyd

Character: Police Officer

Jason Hurst

Character: Police Officer

Jeff Theis

Character: Police Officer

Mario Capra

Character: Police Officer

Marz Jagger

Character: Police Officer

Michael Millazo

Character: Police Officer

Suzie Campbell

Character: Police Officer

Vonda Shrader

Character: Police Officer

Todd Fournier

Character: Policeman #1

Brian Murphy

Character: Policeman #2

Kent Moyer

Character: Policeman #3

Lendy Jones

Character: Policeman #4

Walter McBride

Character: Policeman #5

Enrique Gavilanes

Character: Policeman #6

L.P. Brown III

Character: Policeman #7

Bredy Gamble

Character: Policeman #8

Deborah Kellar

Character: Neighbor #1

Hilda Boulware

Character: Neighbor #2

David Angelis

Character: Bartender #1

Kimberly Krank

Character: Bartender #2

Chuck Record

Character: Bartender #3

John Collins

Character: Jeffrey's Dad (voice)

Sherman Sherman

Character: Victim's Mom (voice)

Josephine O'Keefe

Character: Lady Bartender (voice)