Molly Shannon

Character: Emily Dickinson

Susan Ziegler

Character: Susan Dickinson

Amy Seimetz

Character: Mabel Todd

Brett Gelman

Character: Col Thomas Wentworth Higginson

Jackie Monahan

Character: Lavina Dickinson

Kevin Seal

Character: Austin Dickinson

Dana Melanie

Character: Young Emily

Sasha Frolova

Character: Young Susan

Lisa Haas

Character: Maggie

Stella Chestnut

Character: Mattie Dickinson

Guinevere Turner

Character: Elizabeth Holland

Michael Churven

Character: Josiah Holland

Robert McCaskill

Character: Ralph Waldo Emerson

Lauren Modiano

Character: Adult Mattie

Al Sutton

Character: Judge Lord

John Peña Griswold

Character: Young Austin

Allison Lane

Character: The Widow Kate

Margot Kistler

Character: Young Lavinia

Cynthia Kaplan

Character: Helen Hunt Jackson

Charles Rogers

Character: Samuel Bowles, Jr.

Derrick T. Tuggle

Character: Questioning Soldier

Cole Escola

Character: Dweeby Reader

Celeste Pechous

Character: Emily Norcross

Joel Michaely

Character: Edward Dickinson

Rae C. Wright

Character: Head Shakespeare Lady

Lee Eaton

Character: Parson Mudd

Katherine Willard

Character: Clara Newman Turner

Nick Fisher

Character: Gib Dickinson

Nolan Chestnut

Character: Ned Dickinson

Christian Izziary

Character: Adult Ned

Sally Sockwell

Character: Abby Farley / Wedding Guest

David Albiero

Character: David Peck Todd

Betsy Farrell

Character: Amherst Lady 1

Barbara J. Davy

Character: Amherst Lady 2

Casper Andreas

Character: Joseph Lyman

Morna Ryan

Character: Wedding Guest

Matthew R. Ossenfort

Character: Wedding Guest

Ron Lynch

Character: Opthomologist

David Meyers

Character: Emerson Party Guest

Stacey Alyse Cohen

Character: Tea Lady

Brittini Schreiber

Character: Tea Lady

Kathleen Wilce

Character: Tea Lady

Melissa Barton Ryan

Character: Tea Lady

Pan Ferguson

Character: Tea Lady

Elaine Carberry

Character: Tea Lady

Anna LaRoche

Character: Tea Lady

Alanna Strong

Character: Tea Lady

Alina Cherednychenko

Character: Tea Lady

Caitlin Rodstein

Character: Tea Lady

Linda Vega

Character: Tea Lady

Rowann Gilman

Character: Tea Lady

Samantha Pascale

Character: Tea Lady

Sofia Seneca

Character: Tea Lady

Freia M. Titland

Character: Tea Lady

Kathleen Tawney

Character: Tea Lady

Carolina Parra Moreno

Character: Tea Lady

Holly Battaglia

Character: Tea Lady

Nathalie Baer Chan

Character: Tea Lady

Jo-Ann Victor

Character: Tea Lady

Camelia Cassin

Character: Tea Lady

Kasey Roren

Character: Tea Lady

Julia Drahos

Character: Tea Lady

Stefanie Sparks

Character: Tea Lady

Katie Contini

Character: Tea Lady

Betsy Winslow

Character: Tea Lady

Carmen Cooper

Character: Tea Lady

Katrina Mattson

Character: Tea Lady

Bailie de Lacy

Character: Tea Lady

Annie Pisapia

Character: Tea Lady

Austin Kase

Character: Wedding Guest