Tom Arnold

Character: Nick

Candace Cameron Bure

Character: Holly

Christopher Wiehl

Character: Peter

Barbara Niven

Character: Ginny

Matt Walton

Character: Ben Richards

Allan F. Nicholls

Character: Earl

Kaily Smith Westbrook

Character: Brenda

Heather Remick

Character: Della

Bruce Bouchard

Character: Mr. Covell

Richard Waterhouse

Character: Mr. Jennings

Taylor Ampatiellos

Character: Willy

Lillian Pritchard

Character: Young Holly

Ari Larson

Character: Young Peter

Parma

Character: Nick's Dog

Gary Boyles

Character: Office worker (uncredited)

Dave Kulvete

Character: Elf waiter (uncredited)

Emily George Lyons

Character: Willy's Mom (uncredited)

R.W. Martin

Character: Townsperson (uncredited)