Carey Mulligan

Character: Felicia Montealegre

Bradley Cooper

Character: Leonard Bernstein

Matt Bomer

Character: David Oppenheim

Vincenzo Amato

Character: Bruno Zirato

Greg Hildreth

Character: Isaac

Michael Urie

Character: Jerry Robbins

Brian Klugman

Character: Aaron Copeland

Nick Blaemire

Character: Adolph Green

Mallory Portnoy

Character: Betty Comden

Alexandra Santini

Character: Claudio's Guest #1

Jarrod LaBine

Character: Claudio's Guest #2

Sarah Silverman

Character: Shirley Bernstein

Kate Eastman

Character: Ellen Adler

William Hill

Character: Joseph the Janitor

Valéry Lessard

Character: Younger Actress

Renée Stork

Character: Older Actress

Tim Rogan

Character: Richard Hart

Sara Sanderson

Character: Lil Hart

Yasen Peyankov

Character: Serge Koussevitzky

Julia Aku

Character: Olga

Benjamin Freemantle

Character: Sailor

Harrison Coll

Character: Sailor

Sebastian Villarini-Velez

Character: Sailor

Dario Natarelli

Character: Sailor

Ryan Steele

Character: Sailor

Ricky Ubeda

Character: Sailor

Carlos Sánchez Falú

Character: Bartender

Jeanette Delgado

Character: Fancy Free Woman

Sara Esty

Character: Fancy Free Woman

Ahmad Simmons

Character: NYC Pedestrian Man Dancer

Kyle Coffman

Character: NYC Pedestrian Man Dancer

Byron Tittle

Character: NYC Pedestrian Man Dancer

Yesenia Ayala

Character: NYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer

Skye Mattox

Character: NYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer

Halli Toland

Character: NYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer

Leigh-Ann Esty

Character: NYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer

Gaby Diaz

Character: NYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer

Tanairi Sade Vazquez

Character: NYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer

Lea Cooper

Character: Little Jamie

Soledad Campos

Character: Julia Vega

Zachary Booth

Character: Mendy Wager

Miriam Shor

Character: Cynthia O'Neal

Maya Hawke

Character: Jamie Bernstein

Scott Ellis

Character: Harry Kraut

James Cusati-Moyer

Character: Georgie

John Kroft

Character: Young Man

Scott Drummond

Character: Scott

Gideon Glick

Character: Tommy Cothran

Josh Hamilton

Character: John Gruen

June Gable

Character: Old Lady

Sam Nivola

Character: Alexander Bernstein

Alexa Swinton

Character: Nina Bernstein

Mike Mitarotondo

Character: Bellhop

Colin Anderson

Character: Stage Manager

Kevin Thompson

Character: Director

Rosa Feola

Character: Ely Soloist #1

Isabel Leonard

Character: Ely Soloist #2

Miller Bugliari

Character: Miller

Atika Greene

Character: Nurse

Bernard Kruger

Character: Dr. Kruger

Gabe Fazio

Character: Willard the Assistant

Jordan Dobson

Character: William

Oscar Pavlo

Character: Claudio Arrau (uncredited)

Booch O'Connell

Character: Keg Girl (uncredited)