Abby Ryder Fortson

Character: Margaret Simon

Rachel McAdams

Character: Barbara Simon

Kathy Bates

Character: Sylvia Simon

Elle Graham

Character: Nancy Wheeler

Benny Safdie

Character: Herbert Simon

Amari Alexis Price

Character: Janie Loomis

Katherine Mallen Kupferer

Character: Gretchen Potter

Kate MacCluggage

Character: Mrs. Jan Wheeler

Aidan Wojtak-Hissong

Character: Moose Freed

Landon S. Baxter

Character: Evan Wheeler

Echo Kellum

Character: Mr. Benedict

Mia Dillon

Character: Mary Hutchins

Gary Houston

Character: Paul Hutchins

Mackenzie Joy Potter

Character: Mamma Bunny

Olivia Williams

Character: Witch

Mike Platarote Jr.

Character: Guy in Car

Simms May

Character: Norman Fisher

Zack Brooks

Character: Philip Leroy

JeCobi Swain

Character: Freddy Barnett

Wilbur Fitzgerald

Character: Morris Binamin

Ethan McDowell

Character: Mr. Wheeler

Sloane Warren

Character: Mrs. Fisher

Isol Young

Character: Laura Danker

Eden Lee

Character: PTA Mother

Naida Nelson

Character: PTA Mother

Tahirah Harrison

Character: PTA Mother

Zach Humphrey

Character: Salvation Army Guy

Karen Aruj

Character: Department Store Sales Lady

Judy Blume

Character: Neighbor Walking Dog #1

George Cooper

Character: Neighbor Walking Dog #2

Joan Jackson

Character: Neighbor

Stephen Jackson

Character: Neighbor

Robert Haulbrook

Character: Rough Looking Guy on Bus

Johnny Land

Character: The General

Jennifer Errington

Character: New York Restaurant Waitress

Evan Bergman

Character: Greg the Greeter

Michael Wolk

Character: Rabbi Kellerman

Karen Macarah

Character: Cantor

Ariel DiDonato

Character: Aliyah

Claude Deuce

Character: Gospel Singer / Pastor

Keya Hamilton

Character: Gospel Singer

Tanya J. McClellan

Character: Mrs. Loomis

Dennis Delamar

Character: Mailman

Samantha LeBrocq

Character: Mrs. Potter

Wally White

Character: Protestant Minister

Holli Saperstein

Character: Mrs. Webster

Deborah Helms

Character: Sweet Old Lady Cashier

Cooper Herrett

Character: 17 Year Old Cashier

Gezell Fleming

Character: School Librarian

Jim France

Character: Catholic Priest

Rakeem Massingill

Character: Art Student

Mary Clare Mitchell

Character: Pedestrian