Stephen Baldwin

Character: Chad Chase

Donald Faison

Character: Jonathan

Erin Cahill

Character: Carla Finney

Chynna Phillips

Character: Mrs. Cameron

Isabella Hofmann

Character: Sue

Joey Fatone

Character: Tino

Tessie Santiago

Character: Jennifer

Andrew Morgado

Character: (voice)

Stacey Arwen Raab

Character: Church Member

Michael Monks

Character: Pastor Skip Finney

Samantha Baldwin

Character: Girl in Confessional

London Fuller

Character: London

Andriana Manfredi

Character: Gretchen

Ryan O'Quinn

Character: DJ Jazzy Carl

Diana Matlak

Character: Youth Worker

Bob Sáenz

Character: Bernard

Bridget Albaugh

Character: Sheila

Sedona Fuller

Character: Sedona

Brandy Futch

Character: Reporter

Dennis Nicomede

Character: Church Member

Harvey B. Jackson

Character: Church Member

Wes Halula

Character: Mort

Thor Ramsey

Character: Guy Sides

Christian Janner

Character: Guy in Church

Todd Wilkerson

Character: Dr. Knott

Christopher Shawn Shaw

Character: Efficient Stagehand

Apollo Garza

Character: Church Goer

Ricky Titus-Lam

Character: Jeremy

Clancy McCartney

Character: Blaise

John McGalliard

Character: Laser Tag Stud

William Baldwin

Character: Mr. Cameron