Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

Character: Anthony McCoy

Teyonah Parris

Character: Brianna Cartwright

Colman Domingo

Character: William Burke

Nathan Stewart-Jarrett

Character: Troy Cartwright

Kyle Kaminsky

Character: Grady Smith

Vanessa Williams

Character: Anne-Marie McCoy

Brian King

Character: Clive Privler

Miriam Moss

Character: Jerrika

Rebecca Spence

Character: Finley Stephens

Carl Clemons-Hopkins

Character: Jameson

Christiana Clark

Character: Danielle Harrington

Michael Hargrove

Character: Candyman / Sherman Fields

Rodney L Jones III

Character: Billy

Ireon Roach

Character: Trina

Breanna Lind

Character: Annika

Heidi Grace Engerman

Character: Haley Gulick

Sarah Lo

Character: Samantha

Ro White

Character: Boof

Mark Montgomery

Character: Detective Lipez

Torrey Hanson

Character: Jack Hyde

Cassie Kramer

Character: Librarian

Sarah Wisterman

Character: Celine

Cedric Mays

Character: Gil Cartwright

Alec Silver

Character: Restaurant server

Hannah Love Jones

Character: Young Brianna

J. Nicole Brooks

Character: Dr. Collins

Pamela Jones

Character: Reporter Devlin Sharpe

Genesis Denise Hale

Character: Sabrina

Katherine Purdie

Character: Haley's Mom

Tien Tran

Character: Jane Ji

Mike Geraghty

Character: Police Officer Jones

Aaron Crippen

Character: Police Officer Smith

Dan Fierro

Character: Police Officer Rooney

Nadia Simms

Character: Ringleader

Nancy Pender

Character: TV News Anchor

Johnny Westmoreland

Character: Samuel Evans

Guy Spencer

Character: John Crawley

Daejon Staeker

Character: The Kid

Tony Todd

Character: Candyman / Daniel Robitaille

Virginia Madsen

Character: Helen Lyle (voice)

Ben Marten

Character: Officer Cooke (uncredited)